Metal pans, like the Yomvzake carbon‑steel or Acshio carbon steel models, provide sturdy, heat‑conductive surfaces that promote even browning and can withstand temperatures up to 450 °F. Silicone pans, such as Webake or Sakolla, are flexible, non‑stick, and BPA‑free, but they may not produce the same crisp exterior as metal. Choose metal for a traditional crust and silicone for easy release and dishwasher cleaning.

Measure the interior dimensions of your air fryer basket and compare them to the pan’s outer dimensions; most pans list a width between 7‑13 inches. The Ninja Foodi 12‑cup pan is sized for a 13 × 13 in basket, while the Yomvzake 2‑pack fits a 7.08 × 7.08 in space. If your fryer is smaller than the pan’s footprint, the muffins may bake unevenly or not fit at all.

The metal pans in this list use PTFE‑ and PFOA‑free coatings, which meet FDA standards for food safety. Brands like HYTK and Acshio highlight a triple‑layer, food‑grade coating that resists rust and scratching. To prolong the coating, avoid metal utensils and pre‑grease the pan lightly before each use.

The Acshio 6‑pack provides 24 cups total, giving you enough capacity for daily batches and sharing with friends, while remaining affordable. If you prefer a reusable silicone set, the Webake 2‑pcs jumbo pans give larger cavities for bigger treats, though you’ll need more frequent replacements over time. Consider how many muffins you bake per week and whether you value larger cups or higher quantity of pans.

Yes, all silicone models listed (Webake, Sakolla, Silicone Muffin Tray, etc.) are rated for temperatures from –40 °F to 446 °F, making them safe for ovens, microwaves, freezers, and even instant pots. Their flexible nature also means they can be stacked or folded for compact storage. Just avoid direct flame or broiler exposure, which could damage the silicone.

Silicone pans are generally dishwasher‑safe and can be rinsed quickly thanks to their non‑stick surface; many users report no food residue after a simple wash. Metal pans often require hand washing or a gentle cycle to preserve the coating, and they may need a light spray of oil to prevent sticking. Both types are rust‑resistant if dried properly after washing.

Collapsible handles, featured on Webake and Sakolla silicone pans, provide a safer grip when removing hot pans from the air fryer, reducing the risk of burns. They also make storage more compact because the handles fold flat. If you frequently bake in a cramped kitchen, the handles can be a convenient ergonomic feature.

Standard muffins typically require a 2.5‑2.8 in diameter cup, which you’ll find in most metal pans (e.g., Yomvzake, HYTK) and larger silicone molds. Mini egg bites or cupcake tops are better suited to 2‑2.5 in cups, as seen in the Sakolla 7‑cup silicone set and the Silicone Muffin Tray with 4‑cup design. Matching the cup size to your recipe ensures proper rise and avoids overflow.